State of Vermont v. Donald Starr

We are currently experiencing an issue with scrolling while entering case information on the eFiling system in some locations. If you encounter this inconvenience, you may use the Tab key on your keyboard to move to the next field, or Shift + Tab to navigate backward through fields. We are actively investigating this issue and hope to have it resolved quickly. We apologize for the inconvenience and appreciate your patience as we work toward a fix.

Vermont Judiciary's Electronic Filing and Case Management Systems Have Been Renamed. Read more>>

Vermont Judiciary Transitioning from Webex to Zoom for Remote Hearings. Read more>>

The Orleans County Courthouse at 247 Main Street in Newport is temporarily closed to the public. Court assistance and forms are available at the Orleans Criminal Courthouse located next door at 217 Main Street. All hearings will be held in person at 217 Main Street unless you are notified otherwise.

Click here for information regarding court operations, including participating in remote hearings.

Case Hearing Information

Date: Monday, Aug 24th, 2026
Time: 2:00 PM

Location:
Bennington Criminal Division
200 Veterans Memorial Drive, Bennington, VT 05201

Room

Family/Criminal Courtroom 4

Location Contact Information:
p. 802-447-2727

Judicial Assignments

Judge Valente, John W.
Victim's Advocate: Whitney Kalinowski
Agency: Department of Mental Health
Attorney: Scott Shumaker
Guardian Ad Litem: Terry Parker
Co-Counsel: Jeff Rubin
Plaintiff: State of Vermont
Attorney: Erica A. Marthage
Department of Disabilities, Aging and Independent Living: Department of Disabilities, Aging and Independant Living
Attorney: Benjamin Chater
Co-Counsel: Jared Christopher Bianchi
Defendant: Donald J Starr
Attorney: John J. McCullough

Get Directions

Courthouse Details

State of Vermont v. Donald Starr

#25-CR-02279 / Criminal / Status Conference

Case Hearing Information

Judicial Assignments

Mission Statement

Our Vision